Fighting Fit

Win a fitness package worth more than £3,000

Navigation - link to other main sections from here

Skip Navigation

From The Times
June 30, 2008

Dealing with the enemy

James Hider: Commentary

Israel’s military has, since its birth 60 years ago, nurtured the spirit of “never leave a man behind”. A young Ariel Sharon, the ferocious commando leader who went on to become Prime Minister, pioneered the spirit of risking the lives of soldiers to retrieve the remains of their dead comrades in battle. That spirit has in later years led to some macabre, emotionally charged swaps, as well as vast releases of Arab prisoners in exchange for relatively small numbers of Israeli captives.

Earlier this month Israel freed a man of Jewish descent convicted of spying for Hezbollah in return for the body parts of Israeli soldiers Hezbollah had collected from the battlefields of southern Lebanon during the 2006 summer war. In 1996 Israel exchanged 65 prisoners for the remains of two soldiers. In 1983 it traded 4,600 Palestinian and Lebanese captives to guarantee the release of six soldiers captured in Lebanon.

The ethos derives in part from the assurance the army can give that it will never leave a soldier “alive or dead“ in enemy hands. It also reflects the importance Jewish ritual places on burial in anticipation of resurrection.

Related Links

David from Macclesfield, Hamas mostly use unguided mortars and surface-to-surface missiles to attack civilian towns - so no discrimination in who they kill. Israeli women are only in front-line positions if they volunteer for them. The vast majority of combat troops are men. Same as in UK actually.

Sam Green, Modi'in , Israel

Sam Green, Modi'in , Israel Nothing to with the fact that Israel is a militarized state & women are put in harms way as soldiers then?

David, Macclesfield, England

"Yes - I would like to check it out ... can you give your own source for me to check out?
thanks" -- Jonathan Sivan, Haifa, Israel

I'd like to provide a source if you don't mind- 100% credible

http://www.btselem.org

B'TSELEM - The Israeli Information Center for Human Rights

jayil, london, uk

To Kash: Sorry to tell you the news: citizens often get killed in a war. Israel never aimed specifically against citizens, and if you read history, you will see that IDF rejected a lot of operations that could put Arab citizens on risk. Moreover, Israel gives a lot of money to Hamas and Fatah!

Vito, T.A, Israel

Arabs regularly killed by 'mistake' by Israel. Populated areas (e.g. lebanon) targetted by 'mistake' by Israel.

Looks like the kill stats given by Israel are also a regular mistake.

kash, London,

It’s no surprise that Israel swaps hundreds of live Arabs for the bones of a dead Jew, after all Rabbi Yaacov Perrin said “One million Arabs are not worth a Jewish fingernail.”

Phil Ishmael, Liverpool, England

How sick the thiinking of hamas and the mouslims are. When will they become civilized? It is sick to think like they do.

PHILLIP, Canton, U.S.

Sometimes, Arab civilians die by a mistake when Israel try to target terrorists. And it always happens after they attack civilians in Sderot. Moreover, their fight is defiantly against civilians - read more newspapers, and read Hamas' ideology. Israel cannot accept an Iranian entity next to her.

Vito, T.A, Israel

to Saleh Darwish, Amman, Jordan
Re: "How may children are now being tortured in the “IDF” camps? check it out."

Yes - I would like to check it out ... can you give your own source for me to check out?
thanks

Jonathan Sivan, Haifa, Israel

Darwish, you come from a country with no free press and where you are spoon-fed govt propaganda by your king/dictator to keep him in power. The male/female kill ratio says it all - 2.8% of IDF kills are Pali women, compared to 30% of Hamas kills are Israeli women. Who targets civilians more then?

Sam Green, Modi'in , Israel

An army that inherited a criminal spirit from criminal gangs who established the state of Israel by displacing 800 t. civilians. Anyone knows how many child and infant have been directly killed in cold blood by “IDF” members? How many child are now being tortured in the “IDF” camps? check it out.

saleh darwish, Amman, Jordan

Have your say

* Required

Also in Middle East News

Also in World News

Hebron unrest

Jewish settlers run for cover after Israeli border police threw a stun grenade towards them in the West Bank city of Hebron

Settlers go on the rampage in Palestinian town

Slide Show

Inside Iraq

Flying in Iraq with ’Supermen’

Inside Iraq: Flying in Iraq with 'Supermen'

Pictures of the Day

This timed exposure shows a jet streaking across the night sky as it comes in for a landing at Charlotte-Douglas International Airport

A selection of the best images from around the world

Slide Show

Times Archive: Foundation of Israel

Held by a Haganah military policeman and an unidentified Jewish official, the flag of the newly proclaimed Jewish state of Israel.

Palestine for the Jews

    Comment Central

    Barack Obama holds onto a rebound during a 3 on 3 basketball game

    Anyone for basketball?

    The secret reasoning behind Obama's top appointees

      Most Read

      Skip Most Read

      Today

      MOST COMMENTED

      Skip Editor's Pick

      Today

      MOST CURIOUS

      Skip Most Curious

      Today

      Focus Zone

      Need to Know

      Need to Know

      Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast

      Social Entrepreneurs

      Social Entrepreneurs:

      The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors

      James Bond

      James Bond:

      Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews

      business travel

      Business Travel:

      Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip

      previous next

      Be a Bond Baddie

      Special

      Be a Bond Baddie

      Vanquish your nemesis!

      Services

      The Singapore skyline pictured at night

      Business City Guides

      Overseas contacts and local business information

      Peter Sands...CEO...Standard Chartered.

      Andrew Davidson meets Peter Sands

      Credit Crunched?

      Our Credit Clinic has free help and advice

      Popular Searches on Times Online

      books | chess | chinese democracy | credit crunch | dating | fashion | football | formula 1 | mortgages | need to know | pensions | podcasts | recipes | redundancy calculator | savings | sudoku | us elections | wine

      Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles

      Classifieds 

      Cars

      Skip Cars of the Week

      Saab 9-3

      05/2005
      £13,500

      Bentley Continental

      08/2008
      £109,950

      Mini Cooper

      2006
      £10,750

      Car insurance

      Great car insurance deals online


      Jobs

      Skip Jobs of the Week
      Director of systems development - server based gaming industry

      £Excellent+ executive benefits
      Torres and Partners
      London

      Head of International Programme

      £49,229 - £62,035 pro rata
      Charity Commission
      London/Liverpool/Taunton

      Project Director (m/f)


      Alstom Power
      Europe

      Director Roles

      Six Figure
      Rolls Royce
      Midlands/Europe

      Properties

      Holidays

      Skip Travel of the Week

      Be the first to stay

      At the new sophisticated
      Encore Las Vegas Resort!

      Funway Holidays Int Inc

      Cruise the Islands of Hawaii - Pride of America


      Advertise your holiday property online

      List your property with two leading travel websites


      Travel insurance

      Great travel insurance deals online


      Place your advert now