The man, the films, those blondes. Free DVD collection starting this Sunday

The long-running feud between the oligarchs Boris Berezovsky and Roman Abramovich, once best friends at the Kremlin, descended to an English courtoom yesterday with the $4 billion proceeds of Russia’s oil and aluminium riches at stake.
A gripping account of how the once-Communist nation’s mineral assets were divided up by a handful of men in chats at the Dorchester in London and Munich airport unfolded in a case involving allegations of intimidation, threats and duress.
One of the key players in the tale, the Georgian opposition leader and tycoon Arkady “Badri” Patarkatsishvili, was found dead of a heart attack at his country house in Surrey two months ago. Tests showed that he could have died at any time.
Mr Abramovich is accused of using his privileged proximity to President Putin to intimidate Mr Berezovsky by threatening that the Russian State would confiscate his oil shares.
But if he sold them to Mr Abramovich a close business ally would be released from jail in Russia, it is claimed. Speculation about the true relationship between Mr Berezovsky, now a refugee in Britain, and Mr Abramovich, the Chelsea Football Club owner, has provided fodder for biographers and Kremlinologists for years.
The hearings may finally produce evidence to help to solve the riddle of how Mr Abramovich rose from being a lowly street trader to one of the world’s wealthiest men in little more than a decade.
He was described in the High Court as non-domiciled in Britain but having organised his affairs to hold his interests outside Russia.
The case promises to shed light on how Mr Berezovsky, once regarded as the godfather of the Kremlin, fell out of favour with his young protégé and the rulers of Russia, resulting in his exile and loss of grip on the nation’s assets.
Mr Berezovsky is claiming $2.3 billion (£1.15 billion) from Mr Abramovich over the loss of his shares in the oil giant Sibneft and $1.75 billion losses from his stake in the aluminium company Rusal.
“For many years, the claimant and the defendant were extremely close business associates,” Mr Berezovsky’s court papers state.
In summer 1995, as President Yeltsin was creating the privatised oil company Sibneft by decree, Mr Berezovsky, Mr Abramovich and Mr Patarkatsishvili agreed how to divide the business among them.
By 1996, Mr Berezovsky had become more involved in Russian politics and Mr Patarkatsishvili was responsible for managing Russia’s largest and most politically influential TV channel.
Mr Abramovich proposed that the Sibneft shares held by the older men should be transferred legally to him or his entities, it is alleged.
The agreement was that the pair would continue beneficially to own the shares, held on trust by Mr Abramovich, and they would still be entitled to dividends and payments.
“By the summer of 2001, the claimant’s active opposition to the policies of President Putin resulted in an orchestrated campaign by the Russian State against the claimant’s interests,” Mr Berezovsky’s papers state.
“By contrast, the defendant was and remained at all times close to President Putin and part of his inner circle. In these circumstances, the defendant conducted a campaign of intimidation against the claimant.”
Mr Abramovich allegedly threatened that the older pair’s interests in Sibneft could be expropriated and made it clear they should sell to him “or face the consequences”.
Mr Berezovsky alleges that they were told that, if they sold, Nikolai Glushkov, their close business associate, would be released from prison in Russia.
It is claimed that Mr Patarkatsishvili rang Mr Berezovsky, who was staying at his villa in Cap d’Antibes in France, to pass on the alleged threats and it was conceded the pair had no option but to sell.
Mr Abramovich had intended to make Mr Berezovsky sell his shares undervalued and Mr Berezovsky complied, Barbara Dohmann, QC, for Mr Berezovsky, said.
In a curious twist, not mentioned in the court case, Mr Glushkov was not freed as a result of the deal, although an attempt was allegedly made to spring him from jail by Andrei Lugovoy. Mr Lugovoy is wanted by Scotland Yard on suspicion of the radiation poisoning in London of the dissident KGB spy Alexander Litvinenko.
Ms Dohmann said: “The court will investigate the relationship between the parties, between Mr Berezovsky and Mr Abramovich. Conduct and statements made by Mr Abramovich [were] unlawful and illegitimate. They amounted to a gross breach of trust.”
But Andrew Popplewell, QC, for Mr Abramovich, witheringly rejected the claim, describing it as completely incoherent nonsense that smacked of desperation.
“The arguability of the case depends wholly on oral conversations that are not documented or evidenced in writing at the time or indeed ever,” he told Judge Mackie, QC.
“They are unevidenced conversations which occurred a very long time ago. The defendant regards these claims as hopeless and a complete try-on.”
The hearing was adjourned.
Roman Abramovich
— Born to poor Jewish parents and brought up in the Arctic region. An orphan by age of 4; cared for by extended family
— He moved from selling plastic ducks to becoming a small-scale trader of oil from the refinery in Omsk
— Befriended by Boris Berezovsky in 1992, he moved into the inner circle of powerbroking oligarchs. After Berezovsky’s exile, Abramovich stepped into his mentor’s shoes
— He acquired control of oil company Sibneft and shares in Aeroflot and the aluminium giant RUSAL, surviving several corruption investigations
— He entered politics in 2000; became governor of Chukotka region and lavished his own money on improvement schemes. He bought Chelsea Football Club in 2003
— Abramovich later sold most of his holdings back to the Putin Government at well below their value
— Fortune estimated at £9.6 billion. One of the few oligarchs not to have faced criminal charges
Sources: Times archive; Forbes; Agencies
Boris Berezovsky
— Born to a family of Jewish intellectuals, Boris Berezovsky was an academic mathematician until the state stopped paying his salary in 1989
— He began supporting himself by selling cars to Moscow’s new consumer class and became the country’s first billionaire
— Bankrolling Boris Yeltsin’s 1991 election, Berezovsky was rewarded in Kremlin-controlled privatisations. He bought oil company Sibneft for $100 million – it was later valued at $1 billion
— Played kingmaker to the unknown Vladimir Putin, who later turned on his oligarch backers. Berezovsky fled Russia – and fraud and corruption charges – in 2000. The UK granted him asylum
— He called for the end of Putin’s rule, using his £800 million fortune to fund dissidents
— He has survived several assassination attempts, including one that decapitated his chauffeur, and lives in a Surrey mansion equipped with bulletproof windows and bodyguards
Sources: Times archive; Forbes
Read the training tips and advice that helped our London Triathletes
Times Online's new TV show helps you make the right decisions for your pet
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
The latest travel news plus the best hotels and gadgets for business travellers
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles


Overseas contacts and local business information

A treasure trove of baubles, booty and stylish quests


Our Credit Clinic has free help and advice
2007
£47,700
2007
£41,899
2008
£41,445
Great car insurance deals online
£25,510 – 32,000
Transport for London
London
£50k
NHS
Nationwide
£
£90,000 + PRP
Essex County Council
Essex
100K
Confidential
London
5% below developer pre-launch price!
Luxury Appts, beautiful gardens w/ Thames views
Great Investment, River Views
By Funway – Thailand
from £589pp
Christmas Cruises
From only £995pp
APTs East Coast now from only
£2425pp.
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times. Globrix Property Search - find property for sale and rent in the UK. Visit our classified services and find jobs, used cars, property or holidays. Use our dating service, read our births, marriages and deaths announcements, or place your advertisement.
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
I think Jimbo has it wrong: did not Margartet Thatcher strip council houses from the state and sell them at knockdown prices to the sitting tenants? The inequity is there for all to see.
William, London, UK
Evil greedy men.Stripping a people of and a country of its wealth for themselves.Not unlike Mrs Thatcher when she privatised all the utilities and the oil to make individuals grossly rich. Norway kept the oil and the benifits of its producton remained in Norway.Even the rigs and platforms were built in Norwegian shipyard to give work to the peoples shipyards. And now this moraly bancrupt country of ours gives shelter to theses awfull people.
JIMBO, CHESTER, ENGLAND
They were assisted by Western Banks to pillage Russia. Economic Criminals...Supported always by the British Government because Britain in making money from their Investments. I can't remember Britain ever extraditing Criminally Rich Foreign Nationals.
Martin, Lagos, Nigeria
Why is this case relating to Russian assets is being heard in the UK?
John, Manchester, UK
State assets ending up in private hands? Gracious! I'm glad that couldn't happen here in the UK.
Keith, Newcastle, UK
one question: what does the uk gain from all this? why not send them all back and let them sort out all their problems there...
Paul, Lisbon, Portugal
Couldn't the oligarchs get together and write a book entitled "How to get obscenely rich over-night without really trying"? They would probably double their wealth with the royalties rolling in.
Never was a country more economically stripped from so many, by so few, in such a short space of time. No wonder Russia was in the doldrums after the fall of Communism, there being nothing left to kick-start capitalism.
E J Murray, Kerry, Ireland
And I thought a countryâs natural resources belonged collectively to its people not to a select few .......silly me!
Mark, Blandford, UK
Overnight, USSR State assets suddenly became private property. Nothing less than grand theft. To my certain knowledge, exactly the same thing happened in Poland at the time the Iron Curtain finally fell.
Terry Dell, Weybridge, UK
'Threats and blackmail' well that's something. Add murder and corruption then you get an idea of how these two and others got the money. Read ;Godfather of the Kremlin' by Paul Klebvinov to understand how it all came about. Paul was murdered for his trouble.
David Cornwell, London, UK
roman cant be blamed in any circumstances... mere oral agreement does not hold good in court of law.... moreover the case being discussed is related to internal affair of republic of russia.. and the shares were legally sold.. so there is no question of blame here.. as all the required details will be with russian state authorities... baseless aquisations will not harm roman... i have full faith in him and russian federation that they will come out of this false aquisitions unscathed..
Jitin Nair, Bangalore, India
Noteworthy is that Berezovsky's late business partner Georgian billionaire Badri Patarkatsishvili, who owned 50% of Berezovsky's interest in Sibneft and RusAl, refused to join him in this lawsuit against Abramovich. Patarkatsishvili accepted the settlement offer without protest as just and fair. Noteworthy too is that Patarkatsishvili is alleged to have executed a will appointing Joseph Kay as executor of his estate absent any reference to Berezovsky's claim of 50% ownership of assets he alleges were commingled with Patarkatsishvili. We will never know, however, since the U.S. attorney, Emanuel Zeltser, retained by Patarkatsishvili was flow to Belarus on Berezovsky's private jet on 12 March 2008 where he was arrested and imprisoned by the KGB as he descended Berezovsky's private jet. As in the case of this lawsuit, wealth and power buy you justice or as in the case of Zeltser it buys you injustice. Zeltser will never be allowed to exercise his right to due process of law.
Karon von Gerhke, Alexandria , USA VA
Noteworthy is that Berezovsky's late business partner Georgian billionaire Badri Patarkatsishvili, who owned 50% of Berezovsky's interest in Sibneft and RusAl, refused to join him in this lawsuit against Abramovich. Patarkatsishvili accepted the settlement offer without protest as just and fair. Noteworthy too is that Patarkatsishvili is alleged to have executed a will appointing Joseph Kay as executor of his estate absent any reference to Berezovsky's claim of 50% ownership of assets he alleges were commingled with Patarkatsishvili. We will never know, however, since the U.S. attorney, Emanuel Zeltser, retained by Patarkatsishvili was flow to Belarus on Berezovsky's private jet on 12 March 2008 where he was arrested and imprisoned by the KGB as he descended Berezovsky's private jet. As in the case of this lawsuit, wealth and power buy you justice or as in the case of Zeltser it buys you injustice. Zeltser will never be allowed to exercise his right to due process of law.
Karon von Gerhke, Alexandria , USA VA
Noteworthy is that Berezovsky's late business partner Georgian billionaire Badri Patarkatsishvili, who owned 50% of Berezovsky's interest in Sibneft and RusAl, refused to join him in this lawsuit against Abramovich. Patarkatsishvili accepted the settlement offer without protest as just and fair. Noteworthy too is that Patarkatsishvili is alleged to have executed a will appointing Joseph Kay as executor of his estate absent any reference to Berezovsky's claim of 50% ownership of assets he alleges were commingled with Patarkatsishvili. We will never know, however, since the U.S. attorney, Emanuel Zeltser, retained by Patarkatsishvili was flow to Belarus on Berezovsky's private jet on 12 March 2008 where he was arrested by the KGB as he descended Berezovsky's private jet. As in the case of this lawsuit, wealth and power buy you justice or as in the case of Zeltser it buys you injustice. Zeltser will never be allowed to exercise his right to due process of law.
Karon von Gerhke, Alexandria , USA VA
This case should defile the senses of any person possessed of moral and ethical edicts. In the 1990s, mandated economic reforms in Russia, tied to foreign aid and loans resulted in the establishment of an oligarchical class, thirteen oligarchs to be exact! Thirteen oligarchs who owned 97% of the natural resource wealth of Russia in 1997. Thirteen oligarchs who we unabashedly, unashamedly hail as defenders of democracy, rules of laws, and free market reform. How dare we? Thirteen individuals in all of Russia? Where is the level playing field that is the hallmark of democracy and a free market that rewards merit--enterprise, innovation, hard work and intelligence for rich and poor alike? Both Abramovich and Berezovsky's wealth was obtained during the Yeltsin era through rigged privatization schemes. If ever there were a people who believed themselves to be so rich and so powerful that they are above the law, it is these Russian oligarchs. Indeed. Justice corrupted by wealth and power.
Karon von Gerhke, Alexandria , USA VA