Dean Nelson in Darjeeling
Win a fitness package worth more than £3,000
HUNDREDS of tea pickers in West Bengal, the home of Darjeeling’s so-called “champagne of teas”, are dying of hunger.
Official government figures reveal that more than 570 have died in the past 15 months as tea gardens have closed, leaving impoverished plantation workers penniless and starving.
According to local campaigners, the true death toll is much higher. At Ramjhora estate, where The Sunday Times visited the widows and relatives of the dead last week, more than 300 are said to have starved to death since the garden was closed by its owner three years ago.
This year 50 have already died from anaemia, tuberculosis and malaria – deaths the estate doctor attributes to starvation. Marauding elephants scavenging for food have killed 12 more.
The workers were once a cause célèbre of the left, which railed at the 900 rupees (£11) a month they earned for working long days on the plantations. But the pickers themselves now yearn for those days to return.
Although they were poorly paid, they enjoyed free housing, education for their children, food and healthcare. Since the owner has gone they have no income at all and most are surviving on charitable handouts of 6lb of rice per month to feed families of five and more.
The pickers blame the former malik, or owner, who by abandoning the garden has, they say, taken away their livelihoods and left them on the brink of starvation. There is no alternative work.
The owners say falling tea prices are behind the decline. Local activists, in turn, blame the main political parties. They say strikes led by politicians from the Congress party of Manmohan Singh, the prime minister, and his communist coalition partners – and their use of gangsters to demand political donations – have driven out the owners of 16 tea gardens in Darjeeling and Jalpaiguri districts.
In their absence the same politicians have formed “organising management committees” that rule the estates through fear and line their own pockets. They pay the pickers 35 rupees a day for one or two days a month, while their illegal profits from the sale of the crop often exceed £5,000 each, according to the campaigners.
A human trafficking ring linked to local politicians was recently exposed after smugglers were caught trying to kidnap the daughters of three tea pickers. They confessed that they had promised to sell the girls to a Delhi brothel for £500 each. The parents of the girls were approached by their tea garden’s management committee and told that they would be killed if their daughters gave evidence in court.
The government has put together a £500m rescue package for the gardens. But the campaigners claim most of the money will go to absentee owners to help them reopen their gardens rather than rescue the workers from starvation.
Activists from the Save the Gardens, Save the Workers organisation are scathing about the government’s failure to help the pickers at Ramjhora garden, below the Darjeeling hills. The owner’s lease was cancelled in 2004 after he abandoned the garden and the estate reverted to government control.
Since then between 300 and 400 workers have died from starvation-related illnesses and the garden itself has reverted to jungle. Last week the signs of hunger were all too evident. Parents pointed to their children’s protruding ribs, bulging eyes and distended stomachs.
Sanjay Gurung, 33, said his 30-year-old wife Bishni, the mother of his two young sons, had died of tuberculosis earlier this year. “She wasn’t getting the proper food she needed to keep going. We were eating some rice and salt, but it wasn’t enough and she became so weak. Before the garden closed, no one died from TB,” he said.
Rita Dey, 26, said her husband Robin had died eight months ago, leaving her to raise their two children, aged eight and three. “When the garden closed we searched for work but couldn’t find anything. Gradually he became weaker. He became mad and angry and ill. He worried about feeding the children. He was getting a day’s work occasionally when there were green leaves on the tea bushes. His mother and father, who also worked here, died from hunger. Eventually Robin died too.”
Today she and her daughter Reika are suffering from TB. “Reika has fever and I’m so weak I can hardly walk. I think we will die,” she said.
Dr Jagabandhu Das, who was posted to the garden’s hospital last April, said: “People are dying here because of starvation. They’re suffering from malnutrition and anaemia, which is the main cause of death. Their kidneys fail and they die; 80% of the people here are anaemic.”
Sreerupa Mitra Chaudhury, one of the campaigners, said the government had effectively condemned the pickers to death by failing to help. “The government could help, but it doesn’t. They are killing the tea pickers by doing nothing,” she said.
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2006
£10,750
Great car insurance deals online
£Excellent+ executive benefits
Torres and Partners
London
£49,229 - £62,035 pro rata
Charity Commission
London/Liverpool/Taunton
Alstom Power
Europe
Six Figure
Rolls Royce
Midlands/Europe
From £89,950
Great Investment, River Views
Special Offers now available
At the new sophisticated
Encore Las Vegas Resort!
Cruise the Islands of Hawaii - Pride of America
List your property with two leading travel websites
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths
News International associated websites: Globrix | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
I am struck, like most of people commenting, by the plight of these starving plantation workers in this part of India. So much so that I am prepared to go there and try and help !!! Fortunately we are heading to Goa for a month in January. 2008 My aim is to get a flight to Calcutta. Whilst there hire an English speaking guide and vehicle fill up with supplies and in some small way distribute the aid directly. Thats how much it has affectly me. Could anyone reading this please offer some advice.
Frank Curran, Edinburgh , Midlothian
It is all very well arguing that the owners and the government should be held responsible for the problems on the estate. However, those to blame are in fact the consumers that demand ever cheaper tea. The price of tea has been in steady decline since the early 1960s and, unfortunately for areas such as Darjeeling, the estates in Africa can produce tea much cheaper as wages are up to a third of what they are in India and they are not so crippled by the poor infrastructure that drives up transport costs.
The solution to the problem in Darjeeling, if indeed there is one, is further pursuing a policy already instigated by the Tea Board and the Darjeeling Tea Association, which is to educate consumers about Darjeeling as a brand. Producers in Darjeeling cannot compete with other producers of low grade tea so instead must promote Darjeeling tea as a higher-quality product, with an increased end price that reflects its quality. Only if consumers are prepared to pay can the situation improve
Sophie Ibbotson, Cambridge, UK
The closure of the estates and the subsequent starvation of workers are the unpalatable consequences of an international market that demands ever cheaper prices for tea. In dollar terms tea prices have not gone up in the past 2 decades, despite rising costs in production. Wages on the Indian estates are up to three times higher than those in other tea producing areas such as Rwanda and Burundi and when combined with the high cost of transporting Indian tea to auction, put Indian producers at a distinct disadvantage to their competitors.
The only way in which the Darjeeling estates can hope to compete is by leaving the mass market of low grade teas and focusing on promoting Darjeeling tea as a superior quality product, which the Tea Board has been trying to do. This necessitates an education of the consumer, encouraging to associate quality (and therefore pay more) for regionally specific teas, such as Darjeeling, rather than the multi-regional blends of cheaper, lower-grade teas
Sophie Ibbotson, Cambridge, UK
Unlike the dairy farners here the tea workers have nobody to speak for them.The UK supermarkets insist on flooding the market with cheap teas with buy one get one free offers. The UK consumer is paying the same price for tea as they did in 1977 i.e., 30 years ago!!! The most expensive tea bag costs less than 3p a tea bag ...the cheapest can of coke at 30p a can costs 10 times more! The tea packers still insist on paying less citing supermarket pressure. You decide what is the best way forward..maybe all conscientitous people to write to the supermarkets demanding to know exactly how much they bought the tea in each pack for and boycott the supermarkets and packers that do not comply. This purchase price should also be displayed on the side of each pack so you can then figure out how Tesco and the others make billions in profit each year!
Tea Plucker, London, UK
Like Tee from London (above) I would be very grateful to know who to contact in regard to setting up a Mothers Union linked project to assist these desperate and shamefully isolated people - please could you assist me, thank you!
Jane , taunton, UK
I have been fortunate enough to have visited one of the Tea Gardens in West Bengal, where recent closures have resulted in a change for the worse.
When I first visited the very beautiful Samsing in 2000 the people there, who I am proud to call my friends, were extremely happy, healthy and hard working. However, on my last visit in 2005 I have found that some of the young and happy children whom I first met are now no longer alive, due to disease and other health related issues. The Gardens themselves are starting to look uncared for and the general well being of the population is in decline.
The fact that they are struggling to find work to feed themselves and their families saddens me and that we, as a nation of tea drinkers, can not seem to help. I feel helpless not knowing how to help these good people. The owners should be held responsible.
Where has the reported £500m gone? Not to the workers thats for sure.
Why is the government not acting NOW before it's too late?
S. Kay, London, UK
This is tragic, in a country thriving & becoming a super power the wealth is just not filtering down the line.
Hopefully this article & publicity will shame the powers that be into helping workers.
Maggie Millington, Brittany , France
I don't know why this one in particular, but this story has really made me sad. I can't believe there are people starving to death in this day and age. I have to stop myself eating the food in my house because there is so much. Is there a way I can help?
Lucy, Yorkshire, UK
We in this country can and must do our bit by buying only Tea and Coffee etc that has the Fairtrade symbol !
Steve, London, UK
Can we have an address for the Save the Gardens, Save the Workers campaign. I would like to send money in support of the campaign?
tee, london,