Times Online and news agencies
Win a fitness package worth more than £3,000
Foreign Secretary David Miliband said today Russia and China's decision to block international sanctions against Zimbabwe was "incomprehensible" and confirmed Britain would continue to fight to end suffering at the hands of Robert Mugabe.
A draft resolution, drawn up with the United States, that went before the United Nations Security Council, called for travel bans on the dictator and 13 other leading members of his regime and a freeze on their overseas assets.
It also proposed an arms embargo and the appointment of a special envoy to help with the creation of a new government.
But the move was scuppered by Russia and China's veto. Vitaly Churkin, Russia's UN ambassador, said the sanctions went beyond its mandate to deal with threats to international peace and security.
Mr Miliband said: “I am very disappointed that the UN Security Council should have failed to pass a strong and clear resolution on Zimbabwe.
"In particular, it will appear incomprehensible to the people of Zimbabwe that Russia, which committed itself at the G8 only a few days ago to take further steps including introducing financial and other sanctions, should stand in the way of timely and decisive security council action.
“Nor will they understand the Chinese vote.”
He continued: “The UN still has a key role to play in supporting African efforts to bring an end to this crisis, and we will continue to press for the appointment of a UN envoy.
“All of our efforts will continue to be directed at alleviating the suffering of Zimbabweans. The violence against them must stop. Humanitarian agencies must be granted full access immediately. And a solution must be found that reflects the will of the Zimbabwean people, who voted for change on March 29, but whose will continues to be so brutally denied.”
This morning he told BBC Radio 4's Today programme: “It is right that in the end people have to show their cards and the vote yesterday showed that, in the end, the Russians and the Chinese - I wouldn’t quite say put two fingers up - but effectively they blocked action.
“The Russians and the Chinese were briefing in all sorts of directions. You have to get people to front up because in the end there was hiding going on behind the nods and the winks.
“The Russians signed a G8 statement. Their President at the meeting agreed to the statement which called for, among other things, financial sanctions on the Mugabe regime.
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2006
£10,750
Great car insurance deals online
£Excellent+ executive benefits
Torres and Partners
London
£49,229 - £62,035 pro rata
Charity Commission
London/Liverpool/Taunton
Alstom Power
Europe
Six Figure
Rolls Royce
Midlands/Europe
From £89,950
Great Investment, River Views
Special Offers now available
At the new sophisticated
Encore Las Vegas Resort!
Cruise the Islands of Hawaii - Pride of America
List your property with two leading travel websites
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths
News International associated websites: Globrix | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Glynn...as far as I know the UK sold Zim some training aircraft in the days after independence when Mugabe was still their darling...stupid poms!. At least they're being fairly principled now, the Chinese and South Africa are not. The lack of principles is why the world is such a mess...
David Ashton, Bathurst , Australia
David Ashton, Bathurst, Australia - Live and let live man! First people to sell arms to Zimbabwe were British and just cos they can buy more now, instead of the Brits, from others doesn't mean you have to be sour graped about it. Put it this way - wouldn't you if you could?
Glynn, Kingston,
Hmmm - Paul Owen, Birmingham, UK - I don't know about that...in case Britain starts winning major amounts of medals beating the Americans and the Chinese and Russians
Glynn, Kingston,
un charter, chapter one article 2.7 says the russian and chinese are correct,, but, other chapters can be implemented if talking fails only if all agree.So we have a ways to go yet:-(
jonathan rose, Great torrington, uk
China, South Africa and Russia have all sold arms to Mugabe. For them to have a vote, let alone a veto, on any pronouncement like this is incomprehensible. In fact, the way the UN works is, and has always been, incomprehensible. Since when have they been united on anything?
David Ashton, Bathurst, Australia
Nothing "incomprehensible"about this.
China has backed and trained Mugabe and his goons since "independence" -recently failing to deliver a shipload of deadly arms.
Russia did the same for Mandela.
Both men are Marxist puppets,Mandela with a conviction for terrorism,and with blood on their hands
james allen, manchester, england
The United Nations Charter states that the UN is not authorized to intervene in the internal matters of any state. So, regrettably, it appears China and Russia are correct, that this is not within the mandate of the UN. Voting for the sanctions resolution would appear to violate the UN mandate.
Leo, Ottawa, Canada
The Russins and Chinese have shown the World that they have no interest in democracy by voting against the UN resolution on Zimbabwe. A sad day for the people who have been subjected to years od oppression in Zim and for an innefectual organisation with no teeth - the UN.
Neil Mackay, Melksham, England
People always hold bad thoughts about other countries. i think it's where the argument begins.
Let's stop it,creating a harmony world by trusting other countrymen.
Tom, London, UK
It was inevitable.
I assume Russia and China find Brown and Milliband's cynical, meaningless posturing over Zimbawe as amusing as I do.
There are 2 or 3 dozen African states whose denial of democracy and dictatorial behaviour are at least as bad as Zimbabwe. Why do we hear nothing about them?
chris neame, London , UK
Nothing short of military action will dislodge Mugabe.Sanctions will not work as they will hurt the common people.Mugabe and his band thieves can circumvent sanctions by going on weekly shopping trips China,South Africa and even Britain
benard jemwa, hitchin, uk
China and russia, both communist countries and therefore ruled by godless dictatorships.
Is it any wonder they don't see a problem with the explotation, torture and murder of innocent and wretched people?
kim, london,
Its time to kick the Russians out of the G8 and boycott the Beijing olympics.
Rick, Galena, OH , USA
Well done Russia! This is a message to Milliband: "If you want Russian co-operation, stop spitting on Russia first." How naive of British to expect Russia to jump at their command! The same applies to US. You can't expect Russia to be friendly and surround it with missiles at the same time.
Oleg, Toronto, Canada
China, methinks, has a potential financial interest in Zim. Russia, I don't know about. But, as far as conspiracy theories go, Africa is one of those last untamed areas of the world. The potential for agriculture (focus on world food shortages) is great. So, is Zim therefore a strategic location?
Leo, Stellenbosch, South Africa
"Incomprehensible." How naive is Milliband.
China, ane even Russia really, are run by dictatorships, and they are not going to vote for precedents for the democracies to interfere into the way they run their countries. Russia is angered by the missle defence system and will not cooperate.
William D H Carey, Schoten 2900, Belgium
So your argument is that Russia and China (whose own commitment to democracy is troubling) are using the deaths ,via violence and targeted starvation, of Zimbabweans as leverage to protect non-democratic Iran which is definitely not researching nuclear power to 'wipe Israel off the map'. Good shout
Ruairi Maxwell, London, UK
Where is the mystery? Both countries are likely to have leaders who have illegally accumulated assets overseas and at some future point of time may come under such measures themselves. This is to prevent a precedent from being set.
Ramana Rajgopaul, Pune, India
This is why I shall be having my own private boycott of the Olympics. A country which abuses its own people and colludes in the persecution of those in client states like Zimbabwe has no place hosting this festival of sport. It's time to stand up to the likes of China and Russia before it's too late
Paul Owen, Birmingham, UK
The UN is fundamentally flawed. It allows vile and repressive regimes to have equal say, when they do not offer the same process within their own countries.
End this farce. Scrap the UN and set up a Council of Democratically Elected Countries, then rigorously enforce the entry requirements.
John Weaver, San Javier, Spain
What is "incomprehensible" to Mr Milliband and his flock of sad busybodies is perfectly obvious to the rest of us.
It is called national sovereignty. Zimbabwe, South Africa, China and Russia have no need, or wish, to take instructions from Mr Milliband on how to proceed with their business.
Albert, Paris,
Britain must abide by the UN, else we cannot condemn others who ignore the UN. Order or anarchy? . . . make your choice!
andy, london,
The Chinese put selling gun's to Mugabe's gang before human rights but that's only to expected from them just look how they are reacting to people who may cause them a problem during the forthcoming games. As for Russia we have never been able to trust them since 1945 so why expect it now.
Dave, Mold, UK
Milliband should have mentioned the devious role played by South Africa who are fast showing their Communist colours.Their new "President" will be Zuma backed by the SA Communist Party and Trade Unions so it will get worse.We should get out of South Africa now.Stop all aid and investment.
Bill, Johannesburg, South Africa
Maybe this is just Russia and China's way of telling America and Britain to back of in other areas like Iran.
Udo, Melbourne, Australia
So bad for Britain !!!!
I think that the act of Russians and Chinees is a message for America to end his selfish movements in all the world (Iran).
Also Britain have to know that all what they think do is not allmost in the right form so let this nations resolve they problems alone...
Djerbiano, Tunisia, Tunis
This has nothing to do with Zimbabwe. If G Brown can hardly look at the Russian leader or shake hands with him at the G8 meeting and G Bush brings star war missiles at the Russian boarder, then don't expect Russian support on Zimbabwe.
david, london, uk
The majority of Zimbabweans are in favour of dialogue amongst the main parties under that auspices of Sadc and AU. Frankly, Milliband should listen to both sides of the political divide and not try to impose a solution based on input from one side. A home grown solution is better than an imposed one
Davis, Manchester,
The world just got a bit darker yesterday.
Freedom, self-determination, democracy has suffered a major blow at the hands of those who demand explicit obedience to thier dictatorial will. The UN is no longer open to those screeming for peace and freedom from oppression.
John, London, England
I hope now we see the end to all concessions to Russia's interests by the west. I'll be glad to see missile defense installed in the Czech Republic and accession of Georgia to the Nato Alliance.
james, london,