David Charter in Brussels
Get 20% off your bill at Pizza Express
Gordon Brown and Nicolas Sarkozy issued rival plans to rescue the global financial system yesterday as they jousted over who should take charge of far-reaching regulatory reforms.
The French President sprung into action after Mr Brown issued a detailed document that challenges European leaders to move to “stage two” of his bank rescue plan, and calls for a new Bretton Woods-style conference to reorganise financial regulation.
Not to be outdone, several hours later Mr Sarkozy handed out his own two-page paper demanding a global overhaul of the financial system and “a new form of capitalism”.
Like Mr Brown, he also called for a meeting of key international players before the end of the year and referred to “a new Breton Woods”, saying that this repeated his ideas from a speech to the United Nations last month.
Mr Sarkozy could not compete with Mr Brown’s claim to have been first with the call for a new world order, which the Prime Minister said he initially made after the Asian financial crisis of 1998. But the French President last night gave a press conference spelling out his aims to tackle tax havens and hedge funds, after he has discussed European plans with President Bush this weekend.
Mr Brown went further than Mr Sarkozy by including in his plans the revival of world trade talks to stave off a recession, but Mr Sarkozy took his revenge later by avoiding all mention of Mr Brown’s ideas in his press conference at the close of the first day of the two-day summit.
Either way, the G8 gathering of the world’s biggest economies issued a statement last night supporting the idea of a summit “in the near future”.
EU leaders are expected to back Mr Brown’s initial banking plans today. They will follow the lead of the 15-member eurozone, which accepted Mr Brown’s principles of underwriting interbank lending and taking stakes in struggling banks on Sunday.
Mr Brown went further yesterday. “Stage one was to stabilise the financial system with liquidity, recapitalisation and trying to get funds moving for small businesses and consumers,” he said. “Stage two is to make sure that the problems of the financial system, which started in America, do not recur.” The target was to “root out irresponsibilities and excesses” in the system. “We need supervision and regulation where it has been lacking and where it is necessary, and international co-operation. We need an early warning system and proper co-ordination.”
Mr Brown said the last big shake-up of the financial system — the 1944 Bretton Woods accord —had been designed for a world of national financial markets. In today’s global economy, bodies such as the International Monetary Fund had to be rebuilt He released a paper with eight proposed reforms to supervision and regulation that he wanted implemented by the new year, including new standards for disclosing off-balance-sheet accounting and supervisors for the 30 biggest cross-border corporations in Europe and America — mainly banks and insurance companies.
By the time of the spring meetings of the IMF and the World Bank, Mr Brown wants further reforms, including an overhaul of executive pay “to address compensation structures that encourage excessive and irresponsible risktaking” and instead “align reward with long-term value creation”.
In addition he set out four goals for a new Bretton Woods discussion. It should set up a global early-warning system for financial risks; set international standards of regulation; create effective cross-border supervision; and bring new mechanisms for co-operation in a crisis.
Mr Brown surprised many with a call to restart world trade talks, which collapsed in the summer. “Protectionism may give some countries a short-term advantage but in the long run it will not help. The message must go out that this ‘beggar-my-neighbour’ approach of the past is of no use in the future and one big symbol of that would be a world trade deal saying that protectionism is unacceptable.”
Some may have detected the hand of Lord Mandelson, the Business Secretary, who strove hard but failed to broker a world trade deal while EU Trade Commissioner.
The Prime Minister and his team were keen to emphasise his frenetic activity in the past 24 hours. He had talked to President Lula of Brazil, President Bush, Kevin Rudd, the Australian Prime Minister, Wen Jiabao, the Chinese Premier, and half the leaders of Europe. Mr Brown even found time for lunch with the Party of European Socialists — an event that Tony Blair spent an entire decade avoiding.
Although the financial crisis was grabbing the headlines, the summit was rocked by threats from Italy and Poland to scupper a detailed agreement on cutting carbon dioxide emissions. EU leaders promised last year to cut emissions by 20 per cent, compared with 1990 levels, by 2020.
They also pledged to have renewable energy make up 20 per cent of total sources and to set strict emissions levels for cars. But many EU nations, particularly in industrial Central Europe, are worried about the costs and the impact on industry. Squabbling rivals air grievances, page 39
Gordon’s to do list
By the end of the year
— Overhaul system that forces banks to value toxic debt at its present firesale value, which may underestimate its true worth
— Banks to improve risk disclosures
— Banks to use new rules to police their liquidity
— Toughen regime for credit rating agencies
— Force banks to hold bigger stakes in loans they pass on through securitisation
— Set up central clearing house allowing complex derivatives deals to be known to all parties
— Banks’ scope to park questionable investments “off balance sheet” to be reined in
— Set up cross-border coordination of supervision of each big financial group
By spring 2009
— Stronger incentives for banks not to take excessive risks
— Greater transparency to stop dodgy assets being concealed
— Tighten regulation of firms presently not policed
— Understand and police impact of financial dangers on economies
And now, the world
— Set up global early warning system to identify threats
— Impose uniform standards for regulation
— Cross-border watchdogs to supervise multinationals
— Strengthen ways to cooperate in future crises
Industry sectors news at a glance. Interactive heatmap, video and podcast
The inside track on current trends in the charity, not for profit and social enterprise sectors
Explore your passion for food with the delights of Thai, Indian & Chinese cooking
Read our exclusive 100 Years of Fleming and Bond interactive timeline, packed with original Times articles and reviews
Everything the Business Traveller needs to know to make a better trip
Shortcuts to help you find sections and articles
05/2005
£13,500
08/2008
£109,950
2006
£10,750
Great car insurance deals online
£100k
The National Skills Academy for Social Care
London
£49,229 - £62,035 pro rata
Charity Commission
London/Liverpool/Taunton
£75k - £85k
Confidential
London
Six Figure
Rolls Royce
Midlands/Europe
From £89,950
Great Investment, River Views
$3.5 million
Also avaliable for rent
Times Online Property Search will help you find it
Amazing Far East Offers - Visit Hong Kong
from £499pp
Cruise the Islands of Hawaii - Pride of America
List your property with two leading travel websites
Great travel insurance deals online
Contact our advertising team for advertising and sponsorship in Times Online, The Times and The Sunday Times, or place your advertisement.
Times Online Services: Dating | Jobs | Property Search | Used Cars | Holidays | Births, Marriages, Deaths
News International associated websites: Globrix | Property Finder | Milkround
Copyright 2008 Times Newspapers Ltd.
This service is provided on Times Newspapers' standard Terms and Conditions. Please read our Privacy Policy.To inquire about a licence to reproduce material from Times Online, The Times or The Sunday Times, click here.This website is published by a member of the News International Group. News International Limited, 1 Virginia St, London E98 1XY, is the holding company for the News International group and is registered in England No 81701. VAT number GB 243 8054 69.
Yes Hass, excellent point. Blame Tony Blair and the previous government. Surely TB's Chancellor is the real culprit, so let's leave Gordie out of it.
Andrew J Iddon, London, UK
Fantastic ideas and plans.. go on Brown we believe you and your experience.. Blame Tony Blair and previous governments for this mess..
Hass, london,
It's time to revisit Keynesian economics. The 1944 Bretton Woods agreement failed to adopt Keynes' idea of central bank monetary expansion with a global central bank and a new world reserve currency. Brown's initiative has revitalised British economic leadership - now do right by Keynes.
GPMills, KL, Malaysia
Sorry Michael Djan, Lagos..... but you have to ask yourself who over-extended the UK's borrowing and lending --- and kept on borrowing like there was no tomorrow. Who WAS the man in charge and WHO subsequently got us into this mess --- Gordon Brown
Phil, Preston,
Apparently Brown is walking home to cut down on his carbon emission, this will include the English Channel
D Case, Newquay,
What are they arguing about who gets to close the stable door or who chases the horse
WILLIAM, NORTHAMPTON, ENGLAND
Sarkozy is like a wheeler dealer spiv always looking for the chance to be seen as important. He's a good advert for us to keep the EU (which is largely run for the benefit of the political class) at a distance
David Cartright, Birmingham,
Not content with implementing structures which have led to insolvency thoroughout the British banking system, he know wants to ruin the rest of the world - please God, make someone stop him!
Rick, manchester,
Banks scope to park questionable investments off balance sheet to be reined in.
Hypocrite
Malcolm, London,
What a hoot !
Do it my way !
Gordan is deluded if he thinks that the leaders of the rest of the EEC are as incompitant as he his.
Martin Briggs, Heversham, England
I hope our European neighbours tell the pseudo-saviour of the world that his socialist plans are not welcome. Brown has gone Stalin-Bean-Stalin again. Role on the next general election because I have had more than enough of McDitherer and his chums.
Paul, West Midlands,
I'm in China where people KNOW that GB was in charge all the same years as the US GB who is another failure.
It is NOT seen as strong government to respond so late to financial breakdown.
The EU will see the same. A man made disaster presided over by the two GBs.
Fortunately one is out PDQ!
Richard, Changzhou, China
Isn't it derisive that Brown is being blamed for Britain's woes? The world economy's been primed for a bust for decades. The British should count themselves lucky..lucky that they at least got a Brown at times like this. Ask the Americans
Michael Djan, Lagos,
At last we're seeing what Brown really is-a true Socialist. His aim after destroying the British economy is to now saddle the whole world with Socialist economic ideology by regulation and protectionismt. The Americans should be ashamed of themselves for listening to this buffoon.
George, Birmingham, United Kingdom
What a hoot! Poacher, turned gamekeeper, Brown set up the FSA and put a civil servant in charge of it. It did nothing to regulate the worst excesses of the banking industry. Boom, bust.
Now he has a Road to Glenrothes conversion and proposes what he should have been doing in the last eleven years!
Steve Buckel, Braunau-am-Inn, Austria
Brown had plenty of power when he was chancellor but he never used it. It suits him to blame banks for mistakes he made himself. New international systems will fail the same way they failed in the past. His rescue package looks like another failure so why listen to him yet again.
Christopher H, Canberra, Australia
The to do list is interesting, I wonder if Mr Brown is going to change the way his Government carry out the running of the country. a) Improve the failed FSA, b) stop off book loans (PFI)
c) Tougher credit ratings (True Inflation Rates) d) improve risk disclosures, tell the electrorate the truth.
ATL, KL, Malaysia
The world only has to look at what Browns done to the UK economy to see that it would not be a good idea to follow any of his plans! He inherited a vibrant economy when he took up his tenure and by a process of stealth taxes and regulation has throttled this once proud country.
Jerry, Monmouth, UK
greater transparency to stop dodgy assets being concealed? the hypocrisy of this man knows no bounds- he has £100 billion at least of pfi that he refuses to put on the government books.
we look like were going to skip clapping and cheering into some global brownite social utopia. scared myself then
will, grimsby, uk
Brown(Montgomery) and Sarkozy(Patton) must not forget, that in this war, there is also Merkel(Guderian), Russia, Yellow word, and even american workers. are on the same side. The "enemy" , this time, is Wall Street fat cats and Goldman/Fed. Europe, as a solid block of steel, must lead the charge!
Franco Praderio, suzhou, P R China
"...challenging Europes leaders to move to stage two of his bank rescue plan ..."
The French say that it is not Brown's plan at all. He was just the first to implement a deal agreed by several EU countries. Echoes of Brown's solo Darfur triumph by ignoring the French again? Very naughty.
Tony, Northants,
This is all very Stalinist and arrogant. From other reports it is clear that Sarkozy & Christine Lagarde have done much to bring the EU together in the crisis. Brown needs to remember is that is is the actions themselves that are important, not the prima donna who may or may not have initiated them.
David, London, UK